How To Evaluate Existing Recruiting Systems

Whether you are running a recruiting agency, hiring for an enterprise, or staffing a smaller company, it is important to evaluate your recruiting systems.

Whether you are running a recruiting agency, hiring for an enterprise, or staffing a smaller company, it is important to evaluate your recruiting systems. With the range of different applicant tracking systems now available, it can be tempting to jump on the next big thing in hopes that your recruiting pain points will be assuaged. Instead of moving ahead blindly, it is important to perform a system evaluation so that you know what you are looking for and have an idea how to get there.

Identify What Is Working

In most cases, there will be a few things about the current recruiting system that are working, no matter how dire your recruiting situation may seem or how outmoded your systems may be. Perhaps your application process is simple and attracts a large candidate pool or your in-house referral incentive program secures some of your greatest talent. When looking to identify what is working for your company, make sure to write it down so that you can build around it when devising your new strategy.

Collaborate with Your Main Hiring Staff

Your hiring staff or consultants will never be on board with changes that you make to the recruiting system if they don’t feel that they were included in the evaluation or selection process. In fact, excluding them will alienate your key players and make them less likely to willingly adapt to anything that you change – even if you are trying to make their lives easier. The best recruiting system evaluations come from a collaborative effort between employers and hiring staff.

Share Observations and Goals with Full Staff

After consulting with the main hiring staff and doing some research to pull out what is working with the system, the best course of action is to call together a full staff meeting with all of the staff members that are involved in recruiting in any way and share your observations regarding where the recruiting system is and where you feel it needs to go. This meeting may be a terrific opportunity for your staff to brainstorm and respond to your findings, which can make it easier for you to figure out how to move forward.

Make Small Changes as Needed

If there is anything that you can change to improve your recruiting system and move towards your identified goals without doing a radical system overhaul, do that first. Even if you end up purchasing an ATS or making other dramatic changes eventually, making small changes now may help to ease the implementation process and optimize the eventual result of your labors. Small changes will be easy to adapt to at first and should be easily convertible along with the other aspects of the system that are working.

Prioritize Needs for System Improvement

After you have made all of the changes that you can without purchasing new software, it is the perfect time to perform a reassessment with a specific focus on what you still need to improve in your recruitment process. Prioritize the needs as you create your list and collaborate heavily with your key staff. Keeping this list near your list of what is working will give you a good jumping off point when you start to review ATS software features to begin the selection process.

Software Match

Get matched for free with top HR software.

How many employees are in your organization?

Select the software features you need.

We are matching your needs with the software in our database.

We found matches!
To get the shortlist, please provide your contact info.

By clicking the button above, I agree that Matchr and its approved vendors may use my information to follow up on my request. I also accept the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

We are sorry, Matchr currently does not offer support to countries outside USA, Canada

Thanks for using our Software Matching service

Would you like to schedule a 5-10 minute meeting with a Software Advisor right now?


7,292 people have requested their software matches !

User Friendly
100% Free
HR Tech Experts
Related Resources

How to Choose the Right HRIS Vendor

HRIS, or Human Resources Information Systems, can be a valuable tool for human resources managers and the entire organization. HRIS can ...

Payroll General Ledger and Taxes Defined

Payroll refers to the reimbursement that employees are provided with in exchange for services performed at a company. General ledger ...

HRIS System Impact To Companies

In the ever-changing world in which we live, new technology is continually being developed. This change requires organizational leaders to ...

Important Considerations When Buying a HRIS

Buying a HRIS is a huge decision. Any selection can alter the way your company handles its greatest asset – your employees – for years to ...

Used by top companies

Trusted by